Feedback Evaluation on MACN’s Collective Action Program in Pakistan by an independent international Auditor
In September 2021, the Maritime Anti-Corruption Network (MACN) formally partnered with the Global Compact Network Pakistan (GCNP) to launch the Collective Action Program, an initiative aimed at combating corruption in Pakistan’s maritime sector. Following the successful completion of the program’s first three-year phase, MACN commissioned an international consultancy, to conduct an independent audit assessing the program’s impact, effectiveness, and overall progress.
Audit Process & Stakeholder Engagement-Sept 2024
To ensure credibility and transparency, the auditors requested GCNP to identify at least four key stakeholders who had been actively involved in the program. These participants were selected based on their direct contributions and engagement with the initiative. Once identified, a structured interview schedule was developed and shared with both the stakeholders and auditors to facilitate a seamless review process.
A critical aspect of the audit was its independence, ensuring that the feedback collected was unbiased and candid. To maintain objectivity, GCNP did not participate in the interviews, allowing stakeholders to provide factual assessments of the program’s implementation, challenges, and outcomes.
Key Findings & Impact
The audit process was successfully completed, with all scheduled interviews conducted as planned. MACN’s international team later shared the results with its Pakistan division, reporting highly positive feedback from stakeholders.
The evaluation highlighted several key achievements:
- Strengthened Collective Action: The program successfully fostered collaboration among industry players, encouraging a unified approach to addressing corruption.
- Promotion of Ethical Practices: Stakeholders acknowledged improvements in transparency and ethical business conduct across the maritime sector.
- Addressing Systemic Challenges: The program helped identify and mitigate key regulatory and operational obstacles, contributing to a more structured and fair maritime industry.
Future Prospects & Expansion
The independent audit reinforced the effectiveness of MACN’s initiatives in Pakistan, demonstrating the value of international collaboration in addressing corruption. The positive feedback from stakeholders validated the program’s impact and provided a strong foundation for expanding its scope and reach in the next phase.
This successful evaluation underscores the commitment of all involved parties in fostering a more transparent, ethical, and efficient maritime sector in Pakistan.